Gumroad vs Thinkific: Which Costs Less for Courses (2026)

Gumroad charges nothing until you sell, then keeps 10% + $0.50 of every direct sale. Thinkific charges at least $82 a month and takes no cut of sales made through Thinkific Payments.

Table of Contents

Why This Comparison Matters

Most course creators start by asking one money question: do I pay a cut of each sale, or a fixed monthly bill? Gumroad and Thinkific are close to pure examples of each answer.

Gumroad is a checkout and storefront for digital products with no monthly fee. Thinkific is a course platform (it calls itself a learning management system) with plans starting at $109 a month on monthly billing.

This guide works from the fees Gumroad and Thinkific publish themselves, checked in November 2026. It shows the monthly sales level where Thinkific becomes cheaper, what each fee pays for, and which creators fit each platform.

Quick Verdict

Choose Gumroad if:

  • You sell less than about $1,000 a month in courses priced around $100
  • Your catalog is mostly ebooks, templates, presets, software or short video courses
  • You want Gumroad to act as merchant of record and handle sales tax for you
  • You want a chance at buyers from Gumroad’s Discover marketplace

Choose Thinkific if:

  • You sell $1,100 or more a month on monthly billing, or $800 or more on annual billing
  • Your course needs quizzes, assignments, completion certificates or drip schedules
  • You run live cohorts, coaching calls or a paid community next to your courses
  • You sell training to companies and need group seats or invoicing (Grow plan and up)

Both are cheap to try. Gumroad costs $0 until a sale, and Thinkific offers a 30-day free trial.

Gumroad Overview

Gumroad is a storefront and checkout for digital products such as ebooks, courses, memberships and software. Gumroad’s pricing page lists 10% + $0.50 per transaction for sales through your profile or direct links, and 30% for sales to new customers who find you through its Discover marketplace.

Strengths:

  • No subscription. A month with zero sales costs $0.
  • Gumroad says it has been merchant of record since January 1, 2025, and handles sales tax collection and remittance for its sellers.
  • It sells many digital formats, with license keys for software, pay-what-you-want pricing and multiple file versions.
  • Direct-sale fees drop to 5% + $0.50 once your paid sales pass $20,000 in a calendar month.

Weaknesses:

  • The percentage fee never goes away. At $5,000 a month in sales, Gumroad keeps about $525 before card processing.
  • Discover sales cost a flat 30%.
  • Its features page does not advertise quizzes, assignments, completion certificates or a course player with chapters.

Pricing summary: 10% + $0.50 per direct sale, plus card processing. Gumroad’s fees article says credit card processing (2.9% + $0.30) and PayPal fees are not included in the 10% + $0.50, while the 30% Discover fee includes all processing fees.

Thinkific Overview

Thinkific is a hosted platform for selling courses, communities, memberships, digital downloads, coaching and webinars. It has no free plan. Thinkific’s pricing page, as captured by the Internet Archive on November 15, 2026 (the live page shows our server non-USD prices), lists three self-serve plans in USD: Start at $109/month, Grow at $219/month and Expand at $499/month on monthly billing.

Strengths:

  • Thinkific charges no platform fee on sales processed through its own processor, Thinkific Payments.
  • Every plan allows unlimited courses, digital downloads and coaching or webinar products.
  • Start already includes quizzes, assignments, completion certificates, drip schedules, live Zoom lessons and a community.
  • Payment plans, bundles, order bumps, coupons and abandoned cart emails come with every plan.

Weaknesses:

  • You pay at least $82 a month even in a month with no sales.
  • Start does not include bulk email to students, PayPal, removal of Thinkific branding or the reporting and analytics module. Those begin on Grow at $219 a month.
  • Every self-serve plan caps you at 10,000 current students.

Pricing summary: $109, $219 or $499 a month billed monthly. Annual billing brings those to $82, $164 and $374 a month, which Thinkific describes as a 25% saving. An Enterprise tier called Plus is priced by quote.

Head-to-Head: Pricing and Fees

The table compares published U.S. fees as of November 2026. All figures are in USD.

Fee TypeGumroadThinkific StartThinkific GrowThinkific Expand
Monthly fee (billed monthly)$0$109$219$499
Monthly fee (billed annually)$0$82$164$374
Platform fee per sale10% + $0.500% on Thinkific Payments0% on Thinkific Payments0% on Thinkific Payments
U.S. card processing2.9% + $0.302.9% + $0.302.9% + $0.302.9% + $0.30
Marketplace sale fee30% (Discover)NoneNoneNone
Sales tax handlingIncluded (merchant of record)0.5% per taxed sale0.5% per taxed sale0.5% per taxed sale
Current studentsNo cap listed10,00010,00010,000
Free trialFree to start30 days30 days30 days

Some fees sit outside the table. Thinkific’s payment fees article lists these extras for U.S. businesses: +1.5% on international cards, +1% when a currency conversion is needed and +0.7% on subscriptions and payment plans. Buy now, pay later checkouts cost 6.5% + $0.30, and instant payouts cost 1.5%.

If you use Stripe in place of Thinkific Payments, Thinkific’s gateway fee FAQ says a third-party gateway fee applies on top of Stripe’s own rates. It ranges from 0.5% to 5% depending on the plan, and Thinkific waives it after your first $1 million in sales in a calendar year.

On Gumroad, PayPal fees are charged separately from the 10% + $0.50, and PayPal payouts carry a 2% payout fee.

Gumroad’s cost rises with every sale, while Thinkific’s cost is mostly fixed. That one difference decides which platform is cheaper for you.

Fees and plan prices change often. Confirm current rates on the Gumroad pricing page and the Thinkific pricing page before you commit. This article is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice.

Worked Examples: What You Pay Each Month

These examples assume a $100 course paid with a U.S. card, direct (non-Discover) sales on Gumroad, Thinkific Payments on Thinkific and monthly billing. Each sale costs:

  • Gumroad: $10.50 platform fee + $3.20 processing = $13.70 per sale
  • Thinkific Start: $3.20 processing per sale, plus $109 a month
  • Thinkific Grow: $3.20 processing per sale, plus $219 a month
Monthly sales of a $100 courseGumroad totalThinkific Start totalThinkific Grow totalCheapest
5 sales ($500)$68.50$125.00$235.00Gumroad
10 sales ($1,000)$137.00$141.00$251.00Gumroad
11 sales ($1,100)$150.70$144.20$254.20Thinkific Start
25 sales ($2,500)$342.50$189.00$299.00Thinkific Start
50 sales ($5,000)$685.00$269.00$379.00Thinkific Start
100 sales ($10,000)$1,370.00$429.00$539.00Thinkific Start

Where the Lines Cross

Both platforms charge the same $3.20 in card processing on a $100 U.S. sale. The difference is Gumroad’s $10.50 platform fee, so Thinkific Start pays for itself once you make enough sales to cover $109.

Divide $109 by $10.50 and you get about 10.4. At 10 sales Gumroad is still $4 cheaper, so Thinkific Start starts to cost less at 11 sales of a $100 course a month, or $1,100 in revenue.

On annual billing, Start costs $82 a month. The crossover then drops to 8 sales, or $800 a month.

Grow never beats Start on fees, because both charge the same processing and Grow costs $110 more a month. Against Gumroad alone, Grow wins from 21 sales ($2,100) a month. You move to Grow for bulk student email, PayPal, branding removal and analytics, not to cut fees.

Lower-Priced Products Change the Math

A $20 template on Gumroad costs $2.50 in platform fees plus $0.88 in processing, or $3.38 per sale. That is about 17% of the price.

On Thinkific, the same sale costs $0.88 in processing. The $2.50 difference per sale means Thinkific Start becomes cheaper at 44 sales a month ($880) on monthly billing, or 33 sales ($660) on annual billing.

Gumroad’s $0.50 flat fee hurts most on cheap products. On a $5 download, Gumroad’s platform fee alone is $1.00, or 20% of the sale.

The Sales Tax Line Item

Gumroad’s 10% + $0.50 already pays for tax handling, because Gumroad is the merchant of record. Thinkific’s Sales Tax and VAT Solution adds 0.5% on every non-zero sale to a student in the U.S., Canada, the UK, the EU or Switzerland, even when the tax rate works out to 0%.

On a $100 course that is about $0.50 more per sale on Thinkific. With that fee included, Thinkific Start still wins at 11 sales a month, by $1.00 instead of $6.50.

At Higher Volume

At $10,000 a month, the gap is $941 in Thinkific Start’s favor. Over a year, that adds up to $11,292.

Gumroad narrows the gap above $20,000 in a month. At 250 sales of a $100 course ($25,000), the first 200 sales pay 10% + $0.50 and the last 50 pay 5% + $0.50. Gumroad’s total comes to $3,175 including processing, against $909 on Thinkific Start and $1,019 on Grow.

At that size, check Start’s limits. It allows 200 GB a month of course video bandwidth, 2 administrators and 1 community with 10 spaces. Grow doubles bandwidth to 400 GB and allows 6 administrators and 3 communities.

The Discover Exception

Sales that come through Gumroad’s Discover marketplace cost 30%, processing included. That is $30 on a $100 course.

That fee pays for a buyer you did not have to find yourself. Thinkific has no buyer marketplace, so every Thinkific sale comes from traffic you bring.

Head-to-Head: Course Features

Gumroad is built around the checkout. Thinkific is built around the course and the student.

FeatureGumroadThinkific
Sell coursesYesYes, unlimited
Digital downloadsYesYes, unlimited
Memberships and subscriptionsYesYes
Coaching and webinarsNot listedYes, with Zoom and bookable calendars
QuizzesNot advertisedYes, every plan
AssignmentsNot advertisedYes, every plan
Completion certificatesNot advertisedYes, issued automatically
Drip contentNot advertisedYes, scheduled lessons
CommunityNot advertised1 on Start, 3 on Grow, 10 on Expand
Payment plansNot advertisedYes, every plan
Order bumps and upsellsNot advertisedYes, every plan
Email to buyersBroadcasts and automated workflowsAutomations on every plan, bulk email from Grow
Affiliate programYesAffiliate reporting on every plan
License keys for softwareYesNo
Pay-what-you-want pricingYesNot advertised
Branded mobile appNot advertised$199/month add-on
Built-in buyer marketplaceDiscoverNone

Where Gumroad Wins

Gumroad handles more kinds of digital products with less setup. Gumroad’s features page lists license key generation for software, pay-what-you-want pricing, multiple file versions (for example PDF, ePub and Mobi) and lightweight DRM.

Gumroad also brings a marketplace. Discover can put your product in front of buyers who have never heard of you, at the cost of the 30% fee.

And Gumroad has no student cap, no bandwidth tier and no plan to outgrow. Every feature is available from your first sale.

Where Thinkific Wins

Thinkific wins on the course itself. Its pricing page says Start lets you “Grade student work and issue branded certificates on completion,” and lists unlimited Zoom sessions, bookable calendars and attendance tracking for live cohorts and coaching.

Thinkific also includes course compliance tools that stop students from skipping ahead until they finish a video or lesson. You can release lessons on a drip schedule, run discussions inside lessons and sell a paid community bundled with a course.

The selling tools go further than Gumroad’s too. Every Thinkific plan lists payment plans, product bundles, order bumps, gifting, free trials on subscriptions and abandoned cart emails.

Selling to Companies

Thinkific’s Grow plan adds group orders and invoicing, so you can sell bulk seats to a company and collect payment by invoice. Thinkific’s fee article lists a 0.4% fee on each invoice paid through Thinkific, plus the processing fee for the payment method.

Gumroad does not advertise group seats or invoicing. If corporate training is part of your plan, that alone points to Thinkific.

Head-to-Head: Ease of Use

Gumroad gets a product live faster. You open an account, upload a file, set a price and share the link. Gumroad’s features page sums up the flow as open account, add product, start selling, get paid.

Thinkific asks for more setup because a course has more parts. A typical first week involves building chapters and lessons in the drag-and-drop course builder, adding quizzes or certificates, setting up a site page and connecting Thinkific Payments.

Thinkific does help beginners. Its pricing page mentions AI tools like a Course Outline Generator and step-by-step onboarding, and says you don’t need to be a developer to build your site and courses.

Three ways to compare them:

  • Time to first sale: Gumroad, often the same day.
  • Time to a structured course with tests and certificates: Thinkific, because Gumroad does not offer those tools.
  • Learning curve: Gumroad is a short read. Thinkific has a full help center plus Thinkific Academy training.

If you already run a website and an email tool, Gumroad slots in next to them. Thinkific can also sit beside an existing site: its pricing page says you can use it for learning products only and keep your main website hosted elsewhere.

Payouts, Taxes and Customer Ownership

Payouts

Gumroad’s payout article sets a $100 minimum balance for payouts. You can pick daily, weekly, monthly or quarterly payouts. On the weekly, monthly and quarterly schedules, each sale has a minimum 7-day hold. Daily payouts are limited to U.S. users with eligible bank accounts and at least 4 prior payouts.

Gumroad’s instant payouts cost 3% for U.S. creators, up to $10,000 at a time, once your account has been processing with Gumroad for at least 60 days.

Thinkific lists a standard payout schedule of 2 business days for U.S. businesses on Thinkific Payments. Its pricing page says there is no extra hold period by Thinkific. Instant payouts cost 1.5% in the U.S.

Sales Tax

Gumroad acts as merchant of record. Its pricing page says that since January 1, 2025, it handles sales tax collection and remittance worldwide, so its sellers do not manage tax settings.

Thinkific offers a Sales Tax and VAT Solution through Thinkific Payments. It charges 0.5% on each sale where tax is assessed. Speak to a tax professional about your own obligations on either platform.

Refunds

Gumroad’s fees article says that when a sale is refunded, Gumroad returns its own fee on the refunded portion and keeps only the payment processing part. Thinkific’s fee article says refunds are free to issue, but the fees from the original charge are not returned.

Who Owns the Customer

Both platforms let you keep your buyer list. Gumroad’s features page says you can export your followers and customers at any time. On Thinkific, students enroll on your own site, under your own domain if you connect one.

The difference is where buyers come from. Discover buyers first met you inside Gumroad’s marketplace. On Thinkific, every student came through your own site or marketing.

Who Should Choose Gumroad?

  • First-time sellers who have not made a sale yet and do not want a monthly bill.
  • Sellers under about $1,000 a month in direct sales of a $100 product, or under about $860 a month at $20 a product.
  • Software and template sellers who need license keys, multiple file versions or pay-what-you-want pricing.
  • Creators who want marketplace exposure through Discover and accept the 30% fee on those sales.
  • Sellers who want tax handled for them, since Gumroad acts as merchant of record at no extra charge.

Who Should Choose Thinkific?

  • Course creators selling $1,100 or more a month, or $800 or more on annual billing.
  • Teachers who need structure, such as quizzes, graded assignments, certificates and drip schedules.
  • Coaches and cohort leaders who run live Zoom sessions and a member community alongside a course.
  • Training businesses selling to companies, which need group seats and invoicing on Grow.
  • Creators who use payment plans and upsells to raise the average order size.

Migration Guide: Moving from Gumroad to Thinkific

Most creators who switch move from Gumroad to Thinkific once course sales pass the crossover. Plan for one to two weeks of evening work for a single course.

  1. Start Thinkific’s 30-day trial before you cancel anything. You can build the whole course before paying.
  2. Export your Gumroad customers. Gumroad’s features page says you can export followers and customers at any time.
  3. Rebuild the course in Thinkific. Re-upload your videos and files into chapters and lessons, then add quizzes, assignments or a certificate if you want them.
  4. Set up Thinkific Payments. Using it avoids the third-party gateway fee that applies to Stripe sales.
  5. Recreate your offers. Add prices, payment plans, bundles and coupons to match what you sold on Gumroad.
  6. Enroll past buyers. Thinkific allows manual enrollment on every plan and bulk CSV enrollment from Grow. On Start, either enroll buyers one at a time or send them a 100% off coupon.
  7. Handle memberships with care. Gumroad subscriptions will not move their billing on their own. Ask members to re-subscribe on Thinkific before their next Gumroad charge, then end the Gumroad membership.
  8. Update your links. Point newsletter, social bio and website links to the new Thinkific course page.
  9. Keep Gumroad open for a while. Leave the old product unpublished but your account active until refund and support questions have settled.

The most common mistake is cancelling the old membership before members have rejoined. Run both for one billing cycle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Gumroad cheaper than Thinkific?

Gumroad is cheaper at low sales. For a $100 course, Gumroad costs less up to 10 sales a month, and Thinkific Start costs less from 11 sales ($1,100) on monthly billing or 8 sales ($800) on annual billing.

Does Thinkific take a percentage of sales?

Not on Thinkific Payments. You pay card processing of 2.9% + $0.30 per U.S. card sale. If you use Stripe instead, Thinkific adds a third-party gateway fee of 0.5% to 5% depending on your plan.

How much does Thinkific cost per month in 2026?

Thinkific’s pricing page lists Start at $109, Grow at $219 and Expand at $499 a month on monthly billing. Annual billing brings those to $82, $164 and $374 a month.

Does Thinkific have a free plan?

No. Thinkific’s pricing page says it has no free plan and offers a 30-day free trial instead. You can cancel at any time, including during the trial.

What are Gumroad’s fees in 2026?

Gumroad charges 10% + $0.50 on direct sales plus 2.9% + $0.30 card processing. Sales through its Discover marketplace cost a flat 30%, processing included.

Does Gumroad lower its fees for big sellers?

Yes. Gumroad’s help center says direct sales drop to 5% + $0.50 once your paid sales in a calendar month reach $20,000. The discount resets on the 1st of each month and does not apply to Discover sales.

Can I sell courses on Gumroad?

Yes. Gumroad lists courses alongside ebooks, memberships and software. Its features page does not advertise quizzes, assignments or certificates, so it suits simple video or download courses best.

Which platform is better for beginners?

Gumroad is easier for a first product because there is no subscription and setup takes minutes. Thinkific needs more setup but gives a beginner a structured course builder, a site and student management in one place.

Which platform handles sales tax?

Gumroad says it has acted as merchant of record since January 1, 2025, and collects and remits sales tax for its sellers. Thinkific’s Sales Tax and VAT Solution charges 0.5% on each sale where tax is assessed.

How fast do I get paid on Gumroad and Thinkific?

Gumroad needs a $100 minimum balance and holds sales for at least 7 days on weekly, monthly and quarterly schedules. Thinkific lists a standard payout schedule of 2 business days for U.S. businesses on Thinkific Payments.

Are there hidden fees on Thinkific?

Thinkific lists several extras beyond the plan price for U.S. businesses: +1.5% on international cards, +1% for currency conversion, +0.7% on subscriptions and payment plans, 0.5% for sales tax handling and 1.5% for instant payouts. Its branded mobile app is a $199-a-month add-on.

Can I use Gumroad and Thinkific at the same time?

Yes. Some creators run their main course on Thinkific and sell cheaper templates or software on Gumroad. You would pay the Thinkific plan plus Gumroad’s per-sale fees on whatever sells there.

The Bottom Line

Gumroad and Thinkific charge you in opposite ways, so the cheaper one depends on how much you sell each month.

If you are launching your first product or sell under about $1,000 a month, Gumroad costs less and asks for no commitment. If you sell $1,100 or more a month on monthly billing, or $800 on annual billing, Thinkific Start keeps more of each sale and adds quizzes, certificates, drip schedules and live sessions.

Plan ahead. A creator who expects to pass that line within a few months can save a migration by starting Thinkific’s free trial now. A creator selling templates and software, with no need for tests or cohorts, will likely be happier staying on Gumroad.

Compare Thinkific with Kajabi if you want an all-in-one alternative, or see how Gumroad stacks up against Teachable for another course platform with lower plan prices.

Related Articles

Also see Thinkific vs Podia, Podia vs Gumroad and Payhip vs Gumroad.


About This Research

Chloe Cruz has spent four years writing about eCommerce.

This comparison is based on Gumroad’s pricing page, features page and help center articles on fees and payouts, and on Thinkific’s pricing page (Internet Archive capture of November 15, 2026, in USD) and Thinkific help center articles on Thinkific Payments fees and the third-party gateway fee, all checked in November 2026. The worked examples are calculated directly from those published rates.

Content reviewed and updated: 2026-11-17



Connect With Us

CartCompare is an independent e-commerce platform research site. Have a platform we haven’t covered yet, or think we got a fact wrong? Reach out via ecomcartcompare.com/about.